Hotel a Fly Creek

“Unique property ”

“Our room was somewhat updated, but the bathroom mirror needed to be replaced. When our room was cleaned the garbage pails were not emptied.”

“The property was great for what I needed it for: a cheap place close to the Herkimer Diamond Mine (about 10 minutes). It is dated, but you expect that with the price. The worst part was the AC did not work super great, although not bad enough to tell someone. It was very clean, and staff was friendly, although they did seem annoyed with how late we showed. Love the little kitchen nook but wish it had a coffee maker.”

“Clean, quiet room. Will definitely stay here again.”

“Hotel non nuovo ma comodo da raggiungere e con tutto ciò che può servire. Personale molto gentile.”

“Paul and his staff couldn't have been more accommodating and helpful! Lovely old stately home converted to BnB, with delightful breakfast next day. The suites are large and very comfortable and just dripping with classic furnishings appropriate to a late 19th century stately home.”

“Cancelled my reservation on the day of arrival and they charged me for the whole stay,”

“We had a great stay. Friendly staff, convenient location, room had everything we needed, easy check in / check out experience.”

“I would never stay at this motel again. From the moment we arrived, the experience was terrible. The bed sheets and blankets had a horrible smell, and we had to ask the staff to replace all of the bedding on our very first day. The comforters had cigarette burn holes, everything smelled unpleasant, and the room felt dirty. The bathroom was disgusting. We had to wear flip-flops while showering because it didn’t feel clean at all. The shower curtain was filthy and clearly had not been replaced...

“We had a pretty good experience on that week we wore in Cooperstown”

“The room was clean. Breakfast was not stellar. The air conditioning was top-notch. The grout around the tiles on the bathroom flor was cracked and loose. The hotel was quiet st night. Parking was convenient. All around a decent stay.”

“The Grand Colonial is a great choice for a temporary home in the Herkimer area. So rich in American Revolutionary history, the old mansion is an historic relic that is kept up-to-date by its current owners. Mike was our host, and he couldn't have done more to make us feel welcome and comfortable. We give it our highest recommendation.”

“Charming and comfortable suite. This is an old building, stairs and floors are well out of square and weathered. All things we needed were provided and clean!! Rare and treasured. Restaurant under construction 11/2025. No fuss, easy communication via text.”

“Good option when visiting cooperstown a d baseball hall of tame. Basic needs. Bed small but.comfortable”

“Jennifer & Carol were very accommodating & friendly We look forward to staying here again”

“Lovely, no-frills, very clean and picturesque. Staff were friendly and helpful, grounds and views beautiful, and access and seating at lake were great fun.”

“A beautiful old Colonial Inn with a wonderful staff. Well worth visiting.”