You have to keep in mind that this place is OLD. And hasn't been updated/renovated in probably 40 years. Our room (#502, in the annex building) was exceptionally small, just big enough for the queen sized bed and a couple of chairs. The two of us were squeezing around the furniture and trying (unsuccessfully) to not hit our heads on the low ceiling.
Because this is a small inn, and not a big hotel, the front desk is not staffed 24 hours. Good luck trying to contact someone in the middle of the night. Our neighbor locked herself out of her room at midnight and we called no less than 3 different numbers to get help. Nobody was willing to come in. We were just about to call the police (for lack of any other ideas), when someone did show up and let her in. The ordeal took well over an hour to get resolved.
I also understood from the listing that parking was available. It is not! You are on your own to find public parking. We got lucky, coming off season, and got the last spot in the lot across the street. I don't know what you would do during the busy months.
On the bright side, the location can't be beat. Walking distance to countless restaurants, bars, and shopping.