Noyack Holidays from €1,187

The lobby smelled like spoiled almond milk (who knew that was possible) One of the front door girls was crazy rude and had a friend in the lobby threaten to beat us up for asking for hot water. The rest of the staff was great especially your doorman and your night desk gentleman, but no one's greatness could make up for that one experience. It was mind blowing.

The staff was exemplary! We were celebrating a wedding anniversary and at every turn, we were provided with unexpected tokens and/or service. The accommodations were outstanding and we enjoyed the attention to details throughout the suite. Truly one of our best experiences at a hotel.

The staff is incredible nice. Bell desk was efficient and helpful. Breakfast is great. Elevators were fast but didn’t work great when having to put your key in to select your floor. Otherwise, it was a wonderful stay for me and my family.

The staff went above and beyond when my flight was cxld. due to weather, helping with arrangements for cars, luggage and other items needed

Loved the little window seat overlooking Central Park. Close to the subway, and also walkable to a number of places. Only part that felt a little weird was the bathroom being a fishbowl. There are curtains and stuff to separate the bathroom and bedroom areas, but you can definitely hear everything through the sliding door. I also generally prefer to have a place to unpack (like a dresser), and the wardrobe wasn't ideal. But these are things you can see from the room pics, so it isn't a rating detractor for me.