So, I have been looking for a cost effective motel in Auckland for some time now, and have made some horrible mistakes in the past.
I think I've cracked it with the Papakura Monument Motor Lodge and will definitely make this my destination of choice in the future.
Friendly staff, tidy & clean rooms, Sky TV, free wifi, walking distance to restaurants, free parking, soap (it doesn't seem like much but try going a day without it). All the basics are covered, for a good price, and buttered up with very pleasant staff who make you feel welcome.