The main reasons we will not return are the super small kitchen (without dishwasher), extremely small fireplace (does not fit normal sized wood), and the bed.
The kitchen is super small. If you plan to snack and go out to eat you will be fine. If you plan to cook, pick another place. You have to hand wash everything and with dishes drying on the counter there is zero food prep space, not to mention any room for snacks/drinks etc. Only two small towels provided to use, dirty and then use the same towels to dry and put away all dishes before you leave -- not very sanitary.
The fireplace is very small and normal firewood does not fit. There was no warning of this and Cool Cabins was very unhelpful. They told us to go buy an axe... so we wasted money doing that since the property was not equipped to support the tiny fire place.
Lastly the bed. I was so excited to have a king bed and Tempur Pedic but it is not adjustable and they don't even have sheets that fit it. The sheets were so small they would come off the mattress if you barely moved. We woke up on the bare mattress several times a night. Super uncomfortable sleep here. Please buy sheets that actually fit this bed for future guests.
The only part that was nice was the hot tub but everything else was so uncomfortable or frustrating it was not worth it. Would absolutely not stay here again.